Honest Review of Mean Girls on Broadway - Is It Worth Seeing?

I am Imai, proudly the least confident English speaker on our team.

I finally went to see Mean Girls, the show with the unmistakable pink branding. In this title, “mean” literally points to being unkind, so “Mean Girls” is exactly that: a story about girls who can be cruel.

The musical adapts the 2004 film of the same name and quickly rode the buzz to multiple Tony nominations. I had heard the fanbase was strong, but I honestly was unsure how well I would follow a high school show in English. I took the plunge anyway, and I hope this report helps you choose your next musical.

Click here for discount Mean Girls tickets

About Mean Girls
Theatre guide
Theater tips
Detailed seating guide
Cast interaction
Honest review
Discount tickets

About Mean Girls

Back in high school, many of us watched friends change overnight for a crush, or saw whispers grow into rumors that boxed people into the wrong image. Chances are you have a story like that too.

This show is not just a sparkly teen story. It digs into group dynamics and social pressures that most of us felt during those years.

At the 2018 Tony Awards, the production earned 11 nominations, the most that year. Tickets were tough to get right after that, but a year later you can usually find solid discounts.

Taylor Louderman as Regina, nominated for Best Performance by a Leading Actress in a Musical, is still a must-see. Like “Dear Evan Hansen” or “The Prom,” the show explores adolescence, but it also nudges adults to rethink how we relate to each other. It is an easy recommendation for young audiences and absolutely worthwhile for grownups too.

For more details, see the page below.

Mean Girls show details >>

Mean Girls plays at the August Wilson Theatre

August Wilson Theatre

This venue was originally built by a major theater organization for its more than 15,000 members, with “comfortable and luxurious” as the guiding concept. You can feel that intent the moment you enter: the lobby doors open into an unusually spacious entrance compared with many houses.

The layout makes essentials easy to find, from the merchandise stands to the bar and the coat check.
Arrive early to look around and settle in.

Address: 245 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019

For history, founders, and architecture, see the detailed theater page.

More about the August Wilson Theatre >>

Click images to enlarge

The audio team also cues the LED back screen

A chic chandelier on the mezzanine ceiling

The August Wilson Theatre: Things to know

Voucher pickup window inside the August Wilson Theatre

After you enter, the voucher pickup window is on the left. The long line outside is for ticket holders entering the theater, not for voucher pickup, so don’t join that one by mistake.

Once you exchange your voucher, you do not need to go back outside to rejoin the line. You can head straight in, which is wonderfully efficient.

We recommend exchanging tickets at least 30 minutes before curtain. Don’t forget to bring your voucher and your passport.

There is a large merchandise area in the middle of the lobby.

From accessories to pouches, everything is cute, so be ready to spend a few minutes deciding. While some items are available online, shipping often isn’t always available internationally, so buying onsite is best. For gifts, I recommend the eco bag ($10). When I asked at the counter, the clerk said, “The blue hoodie is today’s top seller” ($70).

I also spotted animal ear headbands and thought, “What is this?” They are a fun nod to the show. See if you can spot where they turn up onstage.

On the left side of the lobby, there is a spacious bar counter.

They even serve a pink smoothie in the show’s signature color. Adorable.

I don’t often see such cute candy displays in other houses. As I browsed, a lady talked to me: “it is cute, right? Are you getting one for your socials?” She was buying hers to post on Instagram.

Click images to enlarge

T-shirts from 30 dollars, hoodies from 70

Our seats and sightlines

Voucher tickets auto-assign “good value” seats, but you cannot choose exact locations. If you worry about getting a tough angle, here is a test I ran. I intentionally bought the lowest priced tier, the rear mezzanine, to see how it looks.

How to read the ticket: MEZZR O 16

Mezzanine Right = mezzanine level, right side (even-numbered seats)
Row O (third from the back), seat 16 (third from the wall)

Mean Girls uses a massive LED wall and wide blocking. Even with a large cast, the set rarely creates blind spots, so our budget corner seats still offered a satisfying view.

When buying voucher tickets, choosing Orchestra W – ZZ or Mezzanine F – M is also perfectly fine for most sightlines.

If you want to see many shows while keeping costs in check, give these sections a try.

After the show: stage-door fun

I waited at the stage door to collect signatures on my Playbill.

Exit the main doors and look for the pink door on the right as your meeting point.

I had forgotten my marker, but the cast had one and kindly signed. They kept greeting fans as long as time allowed, so even joining a bit late was fine. Photos are welcome, and the actors help make sure you fit in the frame.

Because the fanbase is young, the security team wraps things at about 10 PM with a friendly “That is it for tonight. Get home safe.”

I grabbed a photo with Grey Henson, who plays Damian, Cady’s friend. I hadn’t researched him in advance, but he drove many of the show’s best comic beats with charm and a warm, nimble voice, by which I was so excited and practically in love! I later learned he was a 2018 Tony nominee for Best Performance by a Featured Actor in a Musical. No wonder he stood out!

In halting English I said, “It was my first time and I am so excited!” He gave me a big smile and a high five. My heart wouldn’t stop pounding.

I wish I spoke more fluently, of course, but I think the feeling got across.

Click images to enlarge

Post-show impressions

Sixteen-year-old Cady arrives starry-eyed in the big city. In the opener “It Roars,” she sings about new hallways, new crushes, skateboards, and lattes. After ups and downs, she faces her mistakes and closes with “I See Stars.”

When the show asks whether “the Plastics” are as fragile as their name implies, it hits a nerve. What really matters beneath the gloss?

It struck me that students wrestle with similar things everywhere, most likely not just in the US or where I’m from. That small realization felt oddly comforting.

The production also uses the LED wall to visualize how social media spirals out.

It suggests a world where image outruns substance, asking whether too many of us try to accessorize our way to validation.

I am a frequent social media user too, and I had to laugh at myself while scrolling old posts, trying to make myself looking better. Maybe you will feel a twinge of recognition as well.

I don’t speak great English, and I still had a blast

If you love theater but feel intimidated by English, you are not alone.

It is natural to hesitate when tickets cost real money. I hesitated too. But going for it was worth it.

No, I did not catch every line. But the dialogue rarely felt impossibly fast, and the LED visuals carry emotion in vivid, helpful ways.

Minor spoiler: when Cady falls in love, a giant heart blooms across the panels. If you are still worried, watch the film with subtitles as a quick primer and you will be good to go.

I haven’t lived in New York long, but walking out I realized I wanted to shine a little more like Cady, on my own terms. That’s perhaps because Cady met herself at a profound level in the show.

This show nudges you to rediscover your own voice without obsessing over looks.

I hope many of you get to enjoy it, too.

Mean Girls tickets and show information